From numbers to knowledge: Rethinking the role of grades in modern education

For decades, grades have been the gold standard for measuring academic success in India. Board exams, competitive tests, and university cutoffs revolve around numbers, making them the central focus of a student’s life. But as the world moves toward valuing skills, creativity, and emotional intelligence, an increasing number of parents and educators are questioning whether grades alone should define a student’s worth—or education’s true purpose.

---

The Numbers Behind the Obsession

1. Academic Pressure on Students

• According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), over 13,000 students died by suicide in 2021, with academic pressure listed as a major factor. This translates to 35 student suicides daily—a grim reminder of how grades dominate the educational landscape.

2. Parental Expectations

• A 2022 survey by LocalCircles revealed that 78% of Indian parents prioritize grades over extracurricular achievements, fearing poor marks could hinder career opportunities.

3. Rote Learning Dominance

• The Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) 2022 found that 46% of Grade 5 students in rural areas struggle to read a Grade 2-level text, indicating that the emphasis on grades often comes at the expense of actual learning.

---

Why Grades Dominate

Historical Context

• Grades became the cornerstone of India’s education system during colonial rule, with exams designed to filter candidates for administrative roles. This legacy persists, making grades a societal marker of intelligence and success.

Career-Centric Culture

• With a limited number of seats in premier institutions like IITs, AIIMS, and IIMs, grades remain the primary yardstick for eligibility. A report by NITI Aayog highlights that 60% of Indian students compete for less than 2% of available seats in top-tier institutions, fueling the obsession with high scores.

---

The Downsides of Grade-Centric Learning

1. Mental Health Concerns

• A UNICEF study shows that 1 in 7 Indian adolescents suffers from mental health challenges, often linked to academic stress.

2. Skill Gaps

• The India Skills Report 2023 revealed that only 46.2% of graduates are employable, citing a lack of problem-solving and communication skills—areas often overlooked in grade-focused education.

3. Creativity Suppression

• The World Economic Forum predicts that creativity, emotional intelligence, and critical thinking will be among the top skills required by 2025. Yet, these qualities are rarely nurtured in systems that prioritize grades over exploration and curiosity.

---

The Debate: Grades vs. Holistic Development

Parental Perspective

• Many parents argue that grades are necessary to secure scholarships, college admissions, and career opportunities. However, a growing segment of parents, especially in urban areas, are recognizing the value of extracurricular activities and holistic development.

Educators’ Views

• “Grades are just one dimension of a student’s abilities,” says Ramesh Joshi, an education policy expert. “The true purpose of education is to prepare students for life, not just exams.”
• Institutions like The Riverside School in Ahmedabad and Shiv Nadar Schools are pioneering experiential learning models that focus on real-world applications of knowledge.

---

Global Inspiration

1. Finland’s Approach

• Finland’s education system, considered among the best globally, has no standardized testing until high school. Instead, it focuses on skill-building, problem-solving, and collaborative learning.

2. Singapore’s Shift

• Singapore recently moved to de-emphasize grades in primary schools, introducing qualitative feedback to encourage skill development and reduce academic pressure.

---

A Shift in India: Signs of Change

1. National Education Policy (NEP) 2020

• The NEP advocates for holistic education, continuous assessment, and vocational training. It aims to reduce the emphasis on rote learning and promote critical thinking and creativity.

2. Alternative Assessments

• Some Indian schools are piloting project-based assessments and portfolios to measure a student’s understanding beyond exams. The Delhi Government’s Happiness Curriculum and Kerala’s Skill-Based Education Program are steps in this direction.

---

The Way Forward

1. Rethinking Success Metrics

• Schools and policymakers need to redefine success, incorporating emotional intelligence, creativity, and practical skills into evaluation criteria.

2. Parental Awareness

• Parents must recognize that success in life is not solely tied to grades. Workshops and counseling can help shift focus to nurturing well-rounded individuals.

3. Educator Empowerment

• Teachers must be trained to balance academic rigor with experiential learning, creating environments where students feel encouraged to explore their passions.

4. Industry Collaboration

• Employers should focus on hiring based on skills and practical knowledge, not just academic achievements, signaling a broader societal shift.

---

Conclusion

The debate over grades versus learning strikes at the heart of India’s education system. While grades will likely remain a part of the assessment process, they shouldn’t overshadow the broader purpose of education: preparing students for a fulfilling life, not just a high-scoring report card. For India to truly unlock its potential, the focus must shift from marks to mastery, creating a generation of confident, creative, and capable individuals.